Great, one of my Celeb matches is Joey Lawrence!

The full list:

Shane McDermott 98% (an actor who hasn't had a movie since '93)
Alessandro Del Piero 98% (an Italian soccer player)
Andruw Jones 97% (Plays for the Atlanta Braves....boo)
Jonathan Jackson 97% (a soap actor)
Joey Lawrence 97% (Whoa!)

There goes my chance of marrying a celebrity...